A historic church from New Brunswick, sold in the late 1990s, has found a new purpose in the vibrant arts district of Oklahoma City. The Old Trinity Church, constructed in 1842, once the sole Anglican church in Blackville, N.B., holds sentimental value for Shirley Underhill, who claims to be among the last individuals baptized there.
Despite efforts to maintain the church as a memorial, financial constraints led to its sale and relocation. Shirley Underhill, who dedicated over forty years to the Old Trinity Church, participated in its restoration post-deconsecration. Presently, the site features a monument honoring former church ministers and serves as a burial ground for cremated individuals.
David Underhill, a former Blackville resident, reminisces about the church hosting numerous community weddings, including his sister’s. The church also boasted a popular skating rink that attracted locals. Following its move to Oklahoma City, the church morphed through various roles, transitioning from an art studio to a wedding venue, a private residence, and back to an art studio.
The church’s transformation was captured in photos shared by the new owner, eventually displayed in Blackville’s Holy Trinity Anglican Church. Recently sold by realtor Britta Thrift, the property underwent several renovations over the years, posing a unique pricing challenge due to its historical significance and distinctiveness.
Noteworthy buyers, artists Lin and Ernesto Sanchez, have converted the building into Ernesto’s art studio. The couple, drawn to the Paseo Art District’s ambiance, believe the space fosters creativity. They plan to welcome visitors by appointment and on designated walk-in days, ensuring the old church remains accessible for those wishing to experience its legacy.