The Anglican Diocese of Edmonton has raised issues regarding the Alberta government’s utilization of the notwithstanding clause to compel striking teachers to return to work. Bishop Stephen London penned an open letter that was posted online, expressing his apprehensions. While stating he does not aim to engage in political disputes, he contended that the legislation could jeopardize the religious freedoms of Canadians. London argued that invoking the clause to end the teachers’ strike contradicts the Charter’s freedom of association. He emphasized that infringing on one group’s fundamental rights could have broader consequences by impinging on people’s freedom of conscience and religion.
Recently, the United Conservative Party government invoked the notwithstanding clause to hasten back-to-work legislation and resolve a provincewide teachers’ strike that commenced on October 6. London urged Premier Danielle Smith to retract the legislation and allow teachers to resume collective bargaining. Describing the decision as transcending regular politics, he emphasized the moral and spiritual implications. London underscored the importance of democratic rights and freedoms in Canadian society, particularly during a time when democratic institutions globally are under strain, suggesting a reconsideration of the government’s actions.
Heather Jenkins, press secretary to Justice Minister Mickey Amery, defended the government’s use of the notwithstanding clause as a necessary tool to maintain a balance of power between courts and elected bodies. Jenkins stated that employing the clause in this instance upholds the legislature’s authority to act in the public interest. The government’s decision, she added, was made thoughtfully and is deemed vital for students’ return to classrooms. The Catholic Archdiocese of Edmonton has not responded immediately to inquiries regarding London’s concerns.